Theodore's World: “Solar Gate”...Obama's Corruption and Solyndra: DOE Let Taxpayers Take Backseat to Obama’s Buddy Investors in Bankruptcy

« Obama Begs “If You Love Me, Ask Congress to Pass My Jobs Bill” | Main | Houston Family Who’s Daughter Died of Cervical Cancer Defends Rick Perry against Attacks on HPV Vaccine »

September 15, 2011

“Solar Gate”...Obama's Corruption and Solyndra: DOE Let Taxpayers Take Backseat to Obama’s Buddy Investors in Bankruptcy

Morgan Griffith (R-VA) drills the inevitable fall guy for this fiasco, Jonathan Silver, on whether the subordination violated the law.

Guess who the private investors whose interests got put ahead of the taxpayers were! It turns out it was an investment vehicle called Argonaut Ventures I, LLC. And who is Argonaut Ventures.

Two of Solyndra’s largest investors are Argonaut Ventures I, L.L.C. and the GKFF Investment Company, LLC. Both firms are represented on the Solyndra board of directors by Steven R. Mitchell (see Solyndra S-1 page 119). Both are investment vehicles of the George Kaiser Family Foundation of Tulsa, Oklahoma.

George Kaiser was a bundler for President Barack Obama in 2008 election. The Daily Caller has done an excellent job of establishing that Mr. Kaiser visited the White House 16 of the 20 times that Solyndra investors or management visited there

More Solyndra: DoE Let Taxpayers Take Backseat to Obama’s Buddy Investors in Bankruptcy

The news is coming in fast and furious on the Solyndra scandal, which is now looking like it may become one of the prime campaign issues in 2012. In addition to the revelation that the Obama administration pressured the OMB to approve the loan guarantees to Solyndra in order to preserve Vice President Biden’s photo op, more details are coming out about the Solyndra’s collapse, and it looks increasingly like this was one of the most crooked government boondoggles ever. The details are so bad, the mainstream media is now giving them extensive coverage. I’ll give you the conclusion up front: when it was obvious in February 2011 that Solyndra was going to go under and someone was going to take a financial bath, the Obama administration ensured that friends and donors of Barack Obama were protected while the American taxpayers were left out to dry.

For example, ABC news is reporting that DoE officials warned before the loan was even approved (in 2009) that Solyndra would go bankrupt in September 2011, a prediction which turned out to be 100% accurate.

The Obama administration ignored this warning and pressured the OMB to approve a loan to a company founded by one of President Obama’s biggest bundlers, George Kaiser, who visited the White House 16 times in the last two years on behalf of Solyndra. In the wake of Congressional hearings today, it was revealed that it was obvious that Solyndra was going to go under and that someone was going to take a bath on the entire project. In order to delay the PR debacle, the DoE secured bridge financing in the amount of $75M. In exchange for this financing, the DoE allowed the taxpayers’ interest to be subordinated to the interests of the private investors in bankruptcy.

The DoE is attempting to defend this transaction by claiming that without the financing, the company would have had to liquidate in February, which would have somehow resulted in less money for the taxpayers. Megan McArdle, who is an Obama voter who doubts there is actual corruption here, does an excellent job of destroying that contention (and outlining how disastrously indefensible this deal was from start to finish) in this post.

The money shot:

Last February, there was a hail-mary financing round in which the firm raised $75 million. But to secure that deal, the administration had to agree to take a back seat to the new investors. Today, the DOE’s Silver argued that this was the right decision, because quitting then would have meant liquidation, while now it can be reorganized as a going concern. Mr. Silver knows more about Solyndra’s operations than I do, of course, but I am struggling to see how it can be “more valuable” as a going concern manufacturing products that cannot be sold at a profit. This is not a case of a company that has crippling debt or legacy costs, or a temporary cash flow problem, which can be resolved in bankruptcy. It seems to have a permanent structural gap between the cost of manufacturing its products, and the price at which people are willing to buy them.

So what? I hear you cry. Well, for those of you who did not have to take several semesters of accounting, an NOL carryforward allows you to use losses from past years to reduce your taxable income in future years. So if you lose $100,000 in one year, but make $300,000 the year after, you can sort of average them together, and only have to pay taxes on $200,000. (I’m simplifying madly, but this is the general idea.)

These are not supposed to carry through bankruptcy, but in some circumstances they can. Krasting is suggesting that the only reason another company would buy Solyndra is to use its NOLs as a tax shelter.

That’s certainly a good deal for the creditors in line ahead of the government; depending on the price another company is willing to pay for those NOLs, they may get all their money back. But even if DOE gets some money back from the sale, this is not a good deal for the government, because if Krasting is right, 100% of the value of the sale comes from foregone tax revenue. (To be sure, that’s a big if–but it’s all too plausible.) Adding another nine months of losses to the books might have upped the value of the firm to a potential buyer . . . but only because it was transferring even more money out of the government’s pocket and into the pocket of private firms.

What is increasingly clear is that at no point in this entire farce did the Department of Energy give the first thought to the investment provided by the United States taxpayers – and at every opportunity Obama’s political buddies and donors were allowed to benefit from questionable calls from the DoE. I suppose it’s possible, as McArdle believes, that this was merely a coincidence and that no corruption was present, but it’s looking less and less likely every minute.


Solyndra officials made numerous trips to the White House, logs show

Not only does the now-bankrupt solar energy firm Solyndra have a cozy financial relationship with the Obama administration, company representatives also made numerous visits to the White House to meet with administration officials, The Daily Caller has learned.

According to White House visitor logs, between March 12, 2009, and April 14, 2011, Solyndra officials and investors made no fewer than 20 trips to the West Wing.


Breaking: FBI executing search warrants at Solyndra right now.

FBI spokesman says federal agents executing search warrants at California solar firm Solyndra

Major investor makes multiple visits to the White House, his investment gets more than half a bil from the government, skids greased, goes through in record time, and we’re supposed to believe the subject never came up.

This would have been enough to run G.W. Bush out of town on a rail.


Wild Thing's comment......

I sure hope those who have been chosen to take a prison term for this, have copies of data squirreled away.

Look At this......

From an NBC affiliate:

President Obama faces political catastrophe in the form of Solyndra

Obama faces political catastrophe in the form of Solyndra -- a San Francisco Bay area solar company that he touted as a gleaming example of green technology. It has announced it will declare Chapter 11 bankruptcy. More than 1,100 people will lose their jobs

It's not his statements the administration will regret; it's the loan guarantees.

Posted by Wild Thing at September 15, 2011 06:47 AM


This what happens when you believe that you can get something for nothing. This is in essence the mantra of the left. The Sun is free and then they will try to regulate it.

However, with the unions involved and competitive place in the world economy, will put us at the bottom of the barrel and as the most expensive.

There is no way a company in the United States can compete with china in the R and D , manufacture of a product because of all the Government regulations. I.e., OSHA, EPA and the EPA has been granted dictator status by the white house, now the EPA can regulate a company out of business and this is what is happening. Also special priviledges for the Unions.

If a company can't make a profit they wont stay in business very long. With OSHA fines and EPA and exhorbant Unions wages and huge Federal Taxes, they don't last long and they close their doors.

It should be obvious to even the dumbest Liberal that when China pays its workers 10 cents an hour and our employers pay upwards of 25-30 dollars an hour that we simply can't compete. Then the plant closes and more jobs are lost.

Posted by: Mark at September 15, 2011 09:13 AM

Mark you forgot to add all of the taxes and regulations required by the Golden State.

This looks like Obama's Enron.

The media is going to have a tough time looing the other wy on this one.

Posted by: Sean at September 15, 2011 11:16 AM

This $535 million boondoggle of now bankrupt solar panel manufacturer Solyndra in California is a corruption story with legs.

Public sector government spending cannot be equated to private sector spending within the results oriented private sector that cannot not allow for waste, inefficiencies, bloated bureaucracies, ineffective endeavors, deficit spending, insolvencies, and protracted development.

Private risk taking is essential for viable concerns with real sustaining jobs.

Essential risk taking must remain in the private sector where there is recourse.

When risk taking is dumped on the government, it is a business model destine to failure from its very premise.

Far too often, this is something career politicians, particularly those that have spent all their lives in public sector government work (this President, the Vice President and most of this administration), never seem to understand.

It's alien to them and the faculty lounge ideology they can't seem to ever shake off.

Government work today confers immunity from real life. And when government grows as big and unrestrained as it is now, we have a whole populace living in the clouds.

We must have limited government by charter. We are a constitutional republic, not a democracy or some collectivist communal society destined to failure.

Posted by: Carlos at September 15, 2011 11:50 AM

obama has a history of associating with criminals as well as radicals. The only thing between obama and prison is political influence and the media. Maybe he will be so obvious and obnoxious with his crooked activity that public opinion will demand investigations/hearings for impeachment and criminal investigations.

Then again maybe he will slide like the Clintons. Screw it! I'm waiting for the 2012 elections.

Posted by: TomR, armed in Texas at September 15, 2011 04:40 PM

I'm wondering how much of that 500 million found its way back into the coffers of the Democrat Party and Obama campaign?

Posted by: BobF at September 15, 2011 08:21 PM

Great input, thank you so much!!!

Posted by: Wild Thing at September 16, 2011 12:52 AM